Eco-conscious pet care keeps gaining momentum, and you can feel it whenever you shop for everyday essentials like poop bags or grooming wipes.
More people are choosing products that are better for their pets and the planet, which explains why the eco-friendly pet market reached over $43 billion in 2024 and is projected to almost double by 2035. That growth shows just how quickly sustainable choices are becoming the new norm for pet owners across the United States.
Poop bags and grooming wipes are driving much of this demand, putting brands like Pogi’s Pet Supplies and Earth Rated in the spotlight for dog owners who want compostable bags, biodegradable bags, and other eco-friendly options.
This guide compares both brands across materials, compostability, certifications, durability, sizing, and environmental commitments. While each performs well, Pogi’s stands out for its sustainability focus, ingredient transparency, and certified compostable designs.
Let’s explore the details and help you pick the right fit.
Key Takeaways
-
Pogi’s and Earth Rated both offer eco-friendly pet care products, but Pogi’s focuses heavily on plant-based, compostable materials and ingredient transparency.
-
Pogi’s compostable poop bags are certified home-compostable worldwide, while Earth Rated offers compostable lines but with differing certifications.
-
Pogi’s Grooming Wipes are bamboo-based and hypoallergenic, giving them an advantage in natural ingredient safety.
-
Both companies offer durable, leak-proof poop bags, but Pogi’s provides larger sizing and fully plant-based options.
-
Pet parents who want the most sustainable, natural, and skin-safe products tend to choose Pogi’s Pet Supplies.
Brand Overview - Pogis vs Earth rated
Pogi’s Pet Supplies
Pogi’s Pet Supplies has built its reputation on making eco-friendly pet supplies that fit naturally into your daily routine.
The brand’s plant-based compostable poop bags are certified under ASTM D6400, ensuring they meet global standards for safe decomposition in backyard compost and industrial composting facilities. Unlike standard plastic bags or plastic grocery bags, these eco-friendly poop bags help reduce landfill waste and plastic waste that millions of dog owners contribute to each year.
Beyond waste bags, Pogi’s also offers bamboo-based grooming wipes that are hypoallergenic and made from sustainable materials. They’re soft, safe, and free of harsh chemicals, ideal for dogs with sensitive skin or families with multiple dogs.
Even the packaging reflects the brand’s low carbon footprint, using recycled materials and cardboard cores instead of virgin plastic.
Each roll of Pogi’s poop bags is designed with convenience in mind. The bags are wide, leak-proof, and extra thick, making them dependable for large dogs and dog walkers managing pet waste outdoors. Pet parents can also choose between lightly scented or unscented bags, both designed to control odor without being overpowering.
It’s this mix of practicality, eco-friendly design, and ingredient transparency that sets Pogi’s apart as one of the best poop bag choices for anyone who values sustainability.
Earth Rated
Earth Rated has become one of the most recognized names in pet waste management, known for its tough, durable dog poop bags that rarely tear or leak. The brand’s earth-rated poop bags are available in both recycled plastic and compostable bags, appealing to pet owners who want to move away from traditional plastic.
The company’s scented bags feature a distinct lavender-scented option, which many dog owners enjoy for its odor control; however, some find the aroma too strong for everyday use. Earth Rated also includes smart details like stickers that mark the first bag and the end of each roll, making it easier to replace a poop bag dispenser while out at a dog park.
While Earth Rated bags are well known for their thick plastic and sturdy design, Pogi’s offers a more plant-based and biodegradable approach using certified compostable bags and environmentally friendly ingredients.
Both brands perform exceptionally well in daily use, but their focus differs. Earth Rated emphasizes toughness and usability, whereas Pogi’s leads with sustainability and long-term environmental care.
Pogi’s vs Earth Rated: Detailed Comparison
Eco-Friendliness Comparison
Understanding the difference between compostable and recycled materials is key to choosing the right eco-friendly poop bags.
Compostable bags decompose into natural elements that safely return to the earth, while recycled plastic bags reuse existing waste materials to reduce landfill buildup. Both approaches benefit the environment but serve different sustainability goals.
Pogi’s Pet Supplies takes the fully compostable route. Its poop bags are made from plant-based materials and certified under ASTM D6400, ensuring safe decomposition without leaving microplastics behind.
These compostable poop bags naturally break down faster than traditional plastic bags, helping to minimize landfill waste. The brand also integrates sustainable practices across its lineup through recyclable packaging and bamboo fibers in grooming products.
Highlights of Pogi’s eco-friendly design:
-
Certified compostable poop bags made from renewable, plant-based materials.
-
Breaks down completely in both home and industrial composting systems.
-
Uses recyclable packaging and bamboo-based grooming wipes.
-
Reduces overall carbon footprint by avoiding virgin plastic.
Earth Rated, in contrast, focuses on reducing plastic waste through recycled content rather than full compostability.
The brand’s popular poop bags are made from 65% certified post-consumer recycled plastic, which they state gives new life to over five million pounds of plastic that might otherwise end up in landfills. This effort supports a circular use of materials while maintaining the brand’s reputation for durability and thickness.
Key environmental efforts by Earth Rated:
-
Offers a compostable line in addition to its main recycled plastic bags.
-
Uses post-consumer recycled content to reduce landfill waste.
-
Prioritizes sturdiness and long-term usability for multiple dog households.
Usability, Scent, and User Experience
For most pet owners, the real test of a poop bag comes during everyday walks when you’re juggling a leash, treats, and your dog’s unpredictable timing. That’s where usability and scent really matter.
Both Pogi’s and Earth Rated perform well, but their designs cater to slightly different preferences.
Pogi’s Pet Supplies emphasizes ease and comfort. The bags separate cleanly at the perforations, so you don’t waste extra bags trying to pull one apart.
Each roll has a clear “Open Here” label, which is especially useful for night walks or quick cleanups in dim light. The bag openings are wide and flexible, fitting easily over the hand while still holding up against heavy waste loads.
Why pet owners enjoy using Pogi’s bags:
-
Easy to open and separate, no fumbling during walks.
-
Wide openings suitable for big dogs or multiple pets.
-
Light scent or unscented options that don’t overwhelm.
-
Soft, flexible texture that feels comfortable to handle.
When it comes to fragrance, Pogi’s takes a subtle approach. The lightly scented version offers gentle odor control without overpowering your surroundings, while the unscented variant is ideal for sensitive pets or those who prefer a neutral experience.
Earth Rated, on the other hand, focuses on sturdiness and reassurance. The bags have a thicker texture, which gives users confidence when picking up waste from larger dogs.
Many dog owners appreciate that strength, though some report that the bags can be slightly harder to open, particularly outdoors or in cold weather when the plastic stiffens.
What stands out about Earth Rated bags:
-
Thick, durable construction for secure waste handling.
-
Lavender scent that effectively masks odors (though some find it strong).
-
A sticker on the roll that alerts you when the bag supply is running low.
-
Reliable performance for dog parks, long walks, or professional dog walkers.
Price and Value Comparison
Pogi’s Pet Supplies offers one of the most affordable, eco-friendly options in the pet waste category. The brand’s compostable poop bags are competitively priced, even with ASTM D6400 certification and plant-based materials.
For dog owners managing big dogs or multiple pets, bulk packs reduce the cost per bag while maintaining quality. Pogi’s provides strong value for households that want eco-friendly poop bags without paying premium prices.
Earth Rated sits in the moderate price range. Its Earth-rated poop bags made from recycled plastic are cost-effective, while its compostable bags come at a slightly higher price due to material differences.
The brand’s emphasis on durable, leak-proof design makes the added cost reasonable for those who prioritize sturdiness over full compostability.
Overall Differentiation Between Pogi’s and Earth Rated
Both Pogi’s Pet Supplies and Earth Rated have earned trust among pet owners who value eco-friendly products. While their missions overlap, their approaches to materials, design, and environmental responsibility differ in important ways.
Pogi’s Pet Supplies
-
Uses plant-based fibers and compostable materials that decompose naturally rather than becoming plastic waste.
-
Features ASTM D6400 certified compostable poop bags suitable for both home and industrial composting.
-
Bags are wider, easier to open, and convenient for big dogs or multiple pets.
-
Offers lightly scented and unscented options ideal for sensitive pets and fragrance-free households.
-
Incorporates recyclable packaging and bamboo fibers across its product line.
-
Appeals most to eco-conscious pet owners who prioritize compostability, plant-based design, and overall sustainability.
Earth Rated
-
Focuses on recycled plastic innovation, giving post-consumer materials a second life.
-
Uses millions of pounds of recycled content to reduce landfill-bound plastic waste.
-
Produces thick, sturdy bags that many dog owners prefer for durability and leak resistance.
-
Offers a distinct lavender scent that effectively masks odors but may feel strong for some users.
-
Compostable options exist, but most Earth Rated poop bags rely on recycled plastic rather than plant-based materials.
-
Best suited for pet owners who value brand familiarity, toughness, and consistent performance over full compostability.
Pogis Vs Earth Rated - Comparison Table
|
Feature |
Pogi’s Pet Supplies |
Earth Rated |
|---|---|---|
|
Compostability |
ASTM D6400 certified, plant-based, fully compostable |
Some compostable lines, the majority made from recycled plastics |
|
Bag Size |
Large and wide; ideal for big dogs or multiple pets |
Standard size; compostable line slightly smaller |
|
Scent Options |
Unscented or light scent for sensitive users |
Strong lavender scent or unscented variant |
|
Opening & Usability |
Easy to separate with “Open Here” label; smooth handling |
Thick and durable; sometimes harder to open in colder weather |
|
Sustainability Approach |
Plant-based materials, bamboo fibers, and recyclable packaging |
Focused on recycled plastic and waste reduction |
|
Price & Value |
Affordable bulk options with compostable certification |
Moderately priced; cost varies by collection |
|
Best For |
Eco-conscious owners, large dog households, and sensitive pets |
Durability-focused users and long-time brand loyalists |
Make the Eco-Friendly Switch with Pogi’s
Both Pogi’s Pet Supplies and Earth Rated give dog owners reliable ways to manage pet waste responsibly, but their paths toward sustainability take different turns.
Earth Rated focuses on recycled plastic innovation, while Pogi’s goes a step further with plant-based materials that naturally return to the earth. From compostability to scent balance and day-to-day usability, Pogi’s continues to stand out as the brand that makes eco-friendly living effortless.
Pet owners who prefer certified compostable poop bags, soft bamboo grooming wipes, and recyclable packaging often find that Pogi’s checks every box. Each product reflects a promise of transparency, safety, and sustainability values that make cleanup simpler and daily routines greener.
So if you’re ready to upgrade your walks with products that care as much as you do, explore Pogi’s complete line of eco-conscious essentials, including compostable poop bags, earth-friendly poop bags, and bamboo grooming wipes.
Visit Pogis to make the switch to a cleaner, smarter, and more sustainable way to care for your pets.
FAQs
Are Earth Rated poop bags good?
Yes, Earth Rated poop bags are widely recognized by dog owners for their strength, thickness, and leak-proof durability. Made primarily from recycled plastic, they’re designed to handle dog waste efficiently during daily walks. The brand offers both scented and unscented versions, giving pet owners flexibility. While Earth Rated isn’t fully compostable, its bags perform well in durability tests and are appreciated for their eco-friendly approach to using recycled materials.
Who makes the best dog poop bags?
The best dog poop bags depend on your priorities. If you value compostability and plant-based design, Pogi’s Pet Supplies leads with ASTM D6400-certified compostable poop bags made from renewable materials. Earth Rated is another strong contender known for its tough, recycled plastic options. Pet owners looking for the best balance of eco-friendliness, usability, and gentle scent control often consider Pogi’s to be the top choice for sustainable pet waste management.
Are Earth Rated poop bags compostable?
Earth Rated offers a compostable line, but most of its poop bags are made from recycled plastic, not plant-based materials. The compostable version is designed for industrial composting facilities that accept pet waste, but it isn’t suitable for home composting. Pogi’s compostable poop bags, however, are fully plant-based and certified to decompose naturally in both backyard and industrial compost setups.
Where are Earth Rated poop bags made?
Earth Rated poop bags are manufactured in China to the company’s high-quality standards, ensuring strength, leak resistance, and reliability. The brand operates out of Montreal, Canada, and distributes its products worldwide. In contrast, Pogi’s Pet Supplies partners with certified manufacturers that specialize in eco-friendly materials like bamboo fibers and compostable plant-based resins to deliver products focused on environmental safety.
What is the Earth Rated poop bag lawsuit?
The Earth Rated poop bag lawsuit involved consumer concerns over marketing claims related to compostability and biodegradability. Some customers believed all bags were compostable, though only specific lines qualified under certain industrial conditions. The issue led to discussions around transparent labeling within the pet waste industry. As a result, many dog owners now turn to verified compostable options like Pogi’s certified plant-based bags for clarity and assurance.
How long does it take for Earth Rated poop bags to degrade?
Standard Earth-rated poop bags, made from recycled plastic, can take several years to degrade in landfills, much like other plastic-based waste products. Their compostable line breaks down faster under industrial composting conditions, but not in home compost. Pogi’s compostable poop bags, by comparison, are made from renewable materials that fully decompose in home or commercial compost systems without leaving microplastics behind.
What are the most environmentally friendly dog poop bags?
The most environmentally friendly dog poop bags are certified compostable, plant-based options that safely decompose without generating plastic waste. Pogi’s compostable poop bags meet ASTM D6400 standards and are crafted from sustainable materials. They break down completely in composting environments, making them a preferred choice for pet owners looking to reduce landfill waste and maintain an eco-friendly lifestyle.
Is Earth Rated a US company?
No, Earth Rated is a Canadian company headquartered in Montreal, Quebec. It distributes its poop bags and pet supplies across the United States and other countries. The brand is well known in the US market for its lavender-scented and unscented dog bags made from recycled plastic. Meanwhile, Pogi’s Pet Supplies, based in the United States, focuses exclusively on eco-friendly pet care solutions, including compostable poop bags and bamboo grooming wipes.
Are Earth Rated poop bags biodegradable?
Most Earth Rated poop bags are not fully biodegradable since they’re made from recycled plastic. Only its compostable line meets specific degradation standards under industrial conditions. For dog owners seeking genuinely biodegradable options, Pogi’s compostable poop bags are a stronger choice, designed to decompose safely and naturally in both backyard and industrial composting facilities.
Why do some users find Earth Rated bags hard to open?
Some users report that Earth Rated bags can be harder to open, particularly in cold weather when thicker plastic becomes less flexible. The sturdier texture is a trade-off for durability. Pogi’s compostable poop bags, made from softer plant-based materials, are easier to separate and come with “Open Here” labels, making them user-friendly even during night walks or while wearing gloves.
Are Earth Rated’s lavender-scented bags safe for sensitive dogs?
Yes, Earth Rated’s lavender-scented bags are generally safe for dogs. The scent is used to control odors and doesn’t come in direct contact with pets. However, for households with sensitive pets or owners who prefer unscented products, the strong fragrance may be overwhelming. Pogi’s offers lightly scented and unscented compostable poop bags designed for sensitive users who prefer a more neutral cleanup experience.
Is Earth Rated better than Pogi’s?
Both brands have their strengths. Earth Rated is known for thick, reliable recycled plastic bags, while Pogi’s stands out with compostable, plant-based options that are certified eco-friendly. Dog owners seeking toughness and familiarity might lean toward Earth Rated, whereas those prioritizing sustainability, scent sensitivity, and compostable materials tend to prefer Pogi’s Pet Supplies for daily pet waste management.
Do Pogi’s wipes contain harsh chemicals or alcohol?
No. Pogi’s Grooming Wipes are alcohol-free and made with natural, skin-safe ingredients like aloe vera, vitamin E, and awapuhi extract. They’re hypoallergenic and made from sustainable bamboo fibers, ensuring they’re safe for dogs and cats with sensitive skin. These wipes clean effectively without harsh chemicals, offering pet owners an eco-friendly alternative that supports both skin health and environmental care.
